Current Learnings: Developing MEL Handbooks
Yasmin Marriott – 28th January 2025
At inFocus, our ethos is rooted in empowering organisations and networks worldwide to evaluate and sustainably grow the impact of their work. This year, we’re excited to deepen that commitment by sharing open-access learning insights from our work across the sector. Our aim is to provide actionable resources and ideas to help others measure, manage, and amplify their impact. We look forward to collaborating, learning, and growing alongside you in the year ahead.
Our first learning we want to share from our recent work is the development of Monitoring and Evaluation (MEL) Handbooks for the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, Ireland, ADRA International, and Catalyst.
Crafting a robust evaluation handbook is no small feat, but the process reveals valuable lessons for anyone looking to strengthen monitoring and evaluation culture and practice. Here are some key takeaways from our experiences.
1. Existing Manuals and Best Practice Guidance Are Your Starting Point
Avoid reinventing the wheel when developing a manual. We started by analysing existing manuals of other organisations that align with our project objectives. This process helped pinpoint best practices and identify gaps that present opportunities for innovation. For example, we found the European Commission Handbook and the Austrian Development Agency’s Guidelines on Project and Programme Evaluation to be excellent starting points, offering valuable insights and a strong foundation to build upon. If resources allow, it is also invaluable to arrange to speak to the authors of other manuals about their experiences. We found that, generally, people are very happy to share from their experience and learning.
2. Engaging Stakeholders Early for Better Results
During the development phase, consultations with future users of the manual provided invaluable insights into its purpose, necessity, and the specific gaps it sought to address. These discussions also helped establish a baseline understanding of stakeholders’ M&E experience, confidence, and organisational culture, essential context for tailoring content effectively.
For instance, one standout recommendation we received from these consultations was to embed a framework for learning outcomes into the manual. This addition not only enhanced the quality of M&E processes but also ensured insights are actionable and impactful. Based on this feedback, we have continued to integrate similar frameworks into our manuals, aligning them with users’ needs and driving greater value.
3. Co-Writing and Collaborative Development
One surprising insight from internal interviews was that many people didn’t initially know what they needed or wanted from the handbook. By coming prepared with an outline or draft structure, we created a collaborative space for stakeholders to refine and co-create the content.
4. Accessibility from the Start
Building accessibility considerations into the handbook from the beginning was non-negotiable. Ensuring the final product is inclusive and user-friendly is as important as the content itself. Don’t wait until the end to think about accessibility. Some top tips to ensure the manual is accessible, user-friendly and easy to navigate:
- Try including a dedicated “How to Use This Manual” section at the beginning. This section should provide clear guidance on the manual’s structure and how users can quickly locate the information they need.
- Where applicable, create content for specific roles, e.g. those that are actually going to manage evaluations versus those that are more removed.
- At the beginning of each chapter it might be helpful to provide a summary of what the chapter covers and why readers might find it useful.
- Use plain English without jargon (or explain the jargon).
- Incorporate intuitive icons throughout the manual to highlight key features. For instance, use distinct symbols to identify sections containing actionable tips, practical tools, ready-to-use templates, quality assurance checklists, or good practice guides.
- Do not go overboard with colour coding, as it might make the manual inaccessible or less accessible for some users.
What learning have you come across whilst developing Monitoring and Evaluation manuals? We would love to hear your thoughts! Reach out to us via our contact page or on our socials.


















inFocus conducts independent, external 



